FMEA (failure mode and effects analysis)
Design and process FMEA, severity, occurrence and detection, RPN vs action priority, and links to the control plan.
FMEA is a structured way to anticipate how a design or process can fail, how serious that would be, and what controls prevent or detect it.
Types
- DFMEA (design): failure modes of the product design.
- PFMEA (process): failure modes of the manufacturing or assembly process.
- FMEA-MSR: monitoring and system response for electronics in operation (AIAG-VDA).
The core table
For each function or process step: failure mode, effect, severity (S), cause, occurrence (O), current prevention and detection controls, detection (D), and recommended actions.
- Severity: how bad the effect is (1 to 10). Safety and regulatory effects rate 9 or 10.
- Occurrence: how likely the cause is, given prevention controls (1 to 10).
- Detection: how likely current controls are to catch the failure before it reaches the customer (1 = almost certain, 10 = no detection).
RPN vs action priority
The traditional risk priority number is (1 to 1,000). Its weakness: very different risks can have the same RPN. The 2019 AIAG-VDA FMEA handbook replaced it with action priority (AP) tables that rate each S-O-D combination High, Medium or Low, with severity weighted most.
Links to SPC
Process characteristics with high severity or occurrence become special characteristics in the control plan, monitored with control charts and capability targets. Results from SPC update the occurrence ratings.
Questions and answers
When should the PFMEA be updated?
Whenever the process changes, after customer complaints or internal failures, and when SPC or capability data show the occurrence ratings were wrong. It is a living document.
