Interpreting control charts
The Western Electric and Nelson rules, what common patterns mean, how to react, and how to avoid false alarms.
The rules
- Rule 1: one point beyond .
- Rule 2: 9 points in a row on one side of the center line (8 in the Western Electric version).
- Rule 3: 6 points in a row steadily increasing or decreasing.
- Rule 4: 14 points in a row alternating up and down.
- Rule 5: 2 out of 3 points in a row beyond on the same side.
- Rule 6: 4 out of 5 points in a row beyond on the same side.
- Rule 7: 15 points in a row within (either side).
- Rule 8: 8 points in a row beyond (either side).
Patterns and typical causes
- Sudden shift: new material lot, setup change, new operator, fixture moved.
- Trend: tool wear, temperature drift, a filter clogging.
- Cycles: shift changes, daily temperature, rotating operators or gauges.
- Hugging the center line: stratified or mixed subgroups; limits calculated wrong.
- Hugging the limits or a bimodal pattern: two streams mixed in the plotted points.
- Sawtooth (rule 4): alternating between two machines or two operators.
Reacting
- Follow the reaction plan in the control plan.
- Check the measurement first (gauge, operator, recording error).
- Look for what changed at the time of the signal.
- Record the cause and action in a cause log.
- Do not recalculate limits to make a signal disappear.
False alarms
Every extra rule adds false alarms. A sensible default is rules 1, 2, 3 and 5. Add more when you need sensitivity and the team can handle the investigations.
Questions and answers
A point is outside the limits but the part is in spec. Do I need to act?
Yes, investigate. The process has changed even though no bad parts were made yet. Finding the cause now is cheaper than finding it after scrap.
We investigated and found nothing. Now what?
Record it. If it was a genuine special cause, it will often recur and give you another chance. If false alarms are frequent, review the rules in use and the subgrouping.
